You are here

[Wilson, Robert Anton] Coincidance - A Head Test (1988)

Primary tabs

SizeSeedsPeersCompleted
12.3 MiB000
This torrent has no flags.


Coincidance is not a misspelling. It is a dance around coincidence, concerned with synchronicity in literature and life, questioning our insistence on viewing everything in an Aristotelian mind-set, cause always leading to effect. It is a collection of essays, with the odd interview, haiku, and poems tossed in.

Sex is central to a number of the pieces: "Mammary Metaphysics" is a title we can quote. Elsewhere the usual Wilsonian suspects appear: de Sade and Marilyn Monroe, and especially Joyce. There's Ireland, and there is a fair amount of quantum stuff -- synchronicity is central, so Bohm, and Bell's Theorem get their mention. Above all there is Finnegans Wake.

Wilson was a clever man, and he has studied a broad range of subjects -- and studied them well. He's careful in his statements, but shows a marvelous awareness of arguments and counterarguments and facts. The various essays on Finnegans Wake are quite fascinating, as Wilson mines the work for his arguments. He finds a great deal, and much of it is convincing. However, for those without great familiarity with the Wake (and, let's be honest, that means everybody except a handful of Joyce scholars and a few dozen autodidacts) it is fairly tough going. -- and hard to judge the validity of the arguments.

Throughout Wilson has a tendency to heap facts on facts (on top of opinions, under it all), overwhelming (and browbeating) readers. There is too little clarity, too much of a rush of prose. Arguments are not built up but made by providing great bunches of evidence. Normally we favour evidence, cold hard facts, but Wilson doesn't always provide exactly that. Especially with regards to synchronicity and coincidence -- the heart of the matter -- the examples are hap and hazard and often not very convincing.

Worthwhile for his thoughts on Finnegans Wake alone, there is much to be found here, but often it is tough going. On the one hand the collection is too ambitious for its own good, on the other hand Wilson seems to draw back from going whole hog and instead offers other thoughts on other subjects. A frustrating though often thought-provoking collection. Not an easy or comfortable read (in any sense) it is still certainly worth considering.